Saturday, September 25

Amazon Echo vs. Apple HomePod: which one has better speakers? | Digital Trends Spanish

If you haven’t decided on any of the smart speakers yet, we don’t blame you: it’s not an easy decision. It’s not just about choosing a model with the best sound quality or a color that matches your living room. The calls smart speakers They also have important smart home control properties and can work well – or better, or worse – with some music services, real-time TV channels (if you opt for a speaker with a screen), or home security systems.

Here we decided to face two of the most important in the market: Amazon Echo vs. Apple HomePod.

You will be interested in:

One of these speakers opens the door to expand your smart home portal. Since most of us won’t buy one to work with a Ring Video Doorbell and another to manage Apple’s HomeKit through your iPhone, you’ll need to choose carefully.


Apple HomePod

Apple’s HomePod looks a bit old now and hasn’t been updated since its launch in 2018, making it positively dated. After all, the Echo evolved from a cylindrical shape to a sleek dial, so the sturdiness and bulk of the HomePod stand out in comparison.

Amazon Echo 4

Amazon Echo Dot 4 LED Ring Light to Compare to Amazon Echo vs.  Apple HomePod
John Velasco / Digital Trends

It’s usually easy to tell that Apple prioritizes design and ends the conversation there, but Amazon has been stepping up its game. The new model features a bold design according to Digital Trends smart home editor John Velasco in his review of the Amazon Echo 4.

He says the new look has him “in love.” In fact, the black or white spherical shape is ultra-modern and can practically disappear into your space. With subtle controls on the top of the speaker, it also has easy adjustments at your fingertips.

This round goes for the Echo 4 for its modern appeal.

Sound quality

A smart speaker is only as good as its main purpose and for most of us, that’s the sound.

Before we get to that, there’s a serious problem to deal with: If you don’t have an iPhone, you’re not going to hear a peep from the HomePod. To make it work, you must have an iOS device capable of running at least iOS 11.2.5; no other cell phone will work.

You must have an iPhone 5s or later, iPad Mini 2 or later, or 6th generation iPod Touch or later. The HomePod is only for two types of people, the Apple faithful and the Apple faithful. Outsiders do not need to apply.

Apple HomePod

Apple put a lot of effort into making the HomePod sound great and it really does. Music fans will appreciate the exceptional fidelity, powerful, melodious, legitimately tuned bass and clear voices of the smart speaker.

Amazon Echo 4

In comparison, the Echo 4 isn’t as detailed and doesn’t sound as good as the HomePod, but who’s doing that other than tech writers?

That said, the Echo 4 doesn’t disappoint in overall audio quality and is incredibly capable of appeasing audiophiles. If you’re looking for something with even higher fidelity from Amazon, the Echo Studio holds up well.

If you have an iPhone, you can opt for either of the two options. By comparison, the Amazon Echo will work with just about any cell phone, tablet, or device, making it a smart speaker for the masses.

This one is close, but Apple comes out a bit ahead in the sound department.

Music services

If you are one of the few who still maintains a vast audio library on your cell phone, the ability to use music streaming services will be less of a concern for you.

Apple HomePod

Apple Music is the only service that works with voice commands on the HomePod. You can’t ask Siri to play your favorite Spotify or Pandora playlists on HomePod.

However, you can use AirPlay to stream Spotify and some other music or video apps over Wi-Fi.

Unfortunately, this speaker lacks a Bluetooth connection and auxiliary input jack, so you can’t connect non-Apple devices.

Amazon Echo 4

With Amazon Echo, you’re in control and can connect it to a variety of music streaming services (including Apple Music, by the way) while enjoying hands-free mode.

This category is a no-brainer – it goes to the Amazon Echo 4 for sheer ease of use.


Apple HomePod

Apple’s subtle minimalism carries over to the HomePod’s controls; they are invisible push and touch modules that you will never see unless you need them. If you prefer tech gadgets that don’t seem obvious, you’ll love the HomePod.

Amazon Echo 4

Amazon Echo 4 lights up a room with its ring of blue light to compare the Amazon Echo vs.  Apple HomePod

In comparison, the Amazon Echo has real buttons. If you want to be able to see what you’re doing with the controls, the Echo is for you. How you feel about these controls may have to do with the aesthetics of your home design.

Since both devices offer essentially the same controls, we call this a draw.

Price and availability

Apple HomePod

This is where the tire hits the road for many people. If you’re a fan of Apple, you might not mind paying $ 349 (normal price) on this device. But, that’s if you can find one. Apple is recalling this product.

Amazon Echo 4

In comparison, the Echo 4 has a list price of $ 100 and is ready, willing and able to arrive at your home, and Amazon is more than happy to take your money at any time, in almost any country.

The clear winner in this category is the Amazon Echo 4 because it is more affordable and easier to find.

The verdict

Pretty much any way you look at it, the Amazon Echo 4 is the clear winner here. While either speaker will make a solid addition to your home or office, the choice you make will depend on which voice assistant, Siri or Alexa, you prefer and which music streaming service you trust the most.

Still, from price and sound quality, to availability and versatility, there really are no downsides to adding the Amazon Echo 4 to your smart home.

Editor’s Recommendations

var stage = decodeURIComponent(0); var options = JSON.parse(decodeURIComponent('')); var allOptions = {};

if (stage > 0 && window.DTOptions) { allOptions = window.DTOptions.getAll();

Object.keys(options).forEach(function(groupK) { if (options[groupK] && typeof options[groupK] === 'object') { Object.keys(options[groupK]).forEach(function(k) { if (!allOptions[groupK] || typeof allOptions[groupK] !== 'object') { allOptions[groupK] = {}; }

allOptions[groupK][k] = options[groupK][k]; }); } }); } else { allOptions = options; }

var getAll = function () { return allOptions; };

var get = function (key, group, def) { key = key || ''; group = group || decodeURIComponent('qnqb92BhrzmkpqGx'); def = (typeof def !== 'undefined') ? def : null;

if (typeof allOptions[group] !== 'undefined') { if (key && typeof allOptions[group][key] !== 'undefined') { return allOptions[group][key]; } }

return def; };

var set = function (key, group, data) { key = key || ''; group = group || decodeURIComponent('qnqb92BhrzmkpqGx'); data = data || null;

if (key) { if (typeof allOptions[group] === 'undefined') { allOptions[group] = {}; }

allOptions[group][key] = data; } };

var del = function (key, group) { key = key || ''; group = group || decodeURIComponent('qnqb92BhrzmkpqGx');

if (typeof allOptions[group] !== 'undefined') { if (key && typeof allOptions[group][key] !== 'undefined') { allOptions[group][key] = null; } } };

window.DTOptions = { get: get, getAll: getAll, set: set, del: del, }; }());

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *